Getting HD-DVD movies into Plex

28. September 2018 09:31 by Cameron in Home Theater  //  Tags: , , ,   //   Comments

In order to get HD-DVD movies into Plex you need the following:
1. External/Internal HD-DVD drive (an Xbox 360 HD-DVD is cheap on eBay ~$10-15)

2. MakeMKV 

3. AnyDVD HD/DVDFab Passkey (used for decrypting HD-DVD discs)

4. Clown BD (used for converting decrypted HD-DVD movies to M2TS)

5. Plenty of hard drive space as movies can be on average 10-20GB a piece. I use a Synology DS918+ NAS with 12TB of space.

Method 1:

The easiest approach to getting HD-DVD rips is using MakeMKV and selecting the main feature to rip. The process is similar to ripping a standard DVD or Blu-Ray/UHD disc. Just insert the disc in the drive and wait for MakeMKV to recognize the disc. Then load up the title list and select the main feature (the largest title in the list). In terms of audio, most discs have Dolby Digital Plus. Some have TrueHD which is lossless and preferred if available.

Note 1: Some people have mentioned that using an older version of MakeMKV (1.9.9) has had better success than more recent versions. You can try this if you have read errors on some of your discs.

Note 2: The mkvs produced by MakeMKV do not remove the telecine pull-down flag so you are left with a 29.97 fps video. This may not be an issue, but if you want to remove this flag, you will need to demux the mkv using eac3to and then remux (replacing the original video) using something like MKVToolnix.

Method 2:

If MakeMKV can't read the disc, then you may need to try with AnyDVD HD/DVDFab Passkey and rip the entire video disc to a temporary location on your hard drive. Then you can use Clown BD to demux/remux into an M2TS.

Method 3:

Use AnyDVD HD/DVDFab Passkey to take a full ISO backup of your disc. Then mount the disc and attempt Method 1 or Method 2 (point Clown BD to your virtual drive instead).

If these methods are unsuccessful, you might have disc rot and be unable to fully read the disc. In this case, you can evaluate if you want to replace the damaged discs with their Blu-Ray release.

General Notes:

Audio in Plex is a bit finicky depending on your client. If you use the PC client, then nearly any format is supported via direct play. However, if you use a client such as Xbox One or PS4, these might need to transcode Dolby Digital Plus to AAC before being compatible for playback. I found that on my Synology DS918+, this can be troublesome because transcoding DD+ to AAC requires a lot of processing power and sometimes the movie buffers while the audio transcodes.

The bottom line for movie enthusiasts:

Be smart about adding HD-DVDs to your library. Warner Brothers titles are more risky and it's a bit of a mixed bag with them due to disc rot. I have had success with a few titles so far, but I'm not holding my breath on all of my Warner Brothers titles. Also consider that since HD-DVD has been out of commission for the last 10 years, movies will only be as new as 2008. However, there are dozens of titles from that era that are worth collecting.

Why I bought an HD-DVD player in 2018

28. September 2018 09:15 by Cameron in Home Theater, server  //  Tags: , , , , ,   //   Comments

I recently stumbled upon a video on YouTube about adding various upgrades/addons to an Xbox 360. Among these upgrades included the Xbox 360 HD-DVD drive. Since HD-DVD lost the format war against  Blu-Ray back in 2008, it is considered a dead format and likely any movies on the platform are cheaper than their Blu-Ray counterpart. That's when I had the thought to purchase this drive and some HD-DVDs to expand my HD movie collection. Because the drive communicates over USB, it can be used with a PC and you can either play the discs directly or rip them to play them on your media server. I went to eBay and found a 46 movie lot with two HD-DVD drives for $60 which is a huge discount on movies.

I am now in the process of converting these movies with MakeMKV and AnyDVD HD/Clown BD. Most of the discs I've tried have worked with MakeMKV, but a few might need a different approach. I've been able to rip most of my library so far without issue, but some of the Warner Brothers titles are more difficult to rip due to their impending disc rot. Luckily, I was able to rip "A Clockwork Orange", "I am Legend", and "Constantine" so far and there doesn't appear to be any disc rot on these. I have about 10-15 more Warner Brothers titles to assess, but hopefully I can get through most of them. Disc rot is inevitable on Warner Brothers HD-DVDs so if you have any of these still, get them backed up ASAP!

I will be looking for single movies or smaller lots that don't contain Warner Brothers movies in the future. However, even if only 20-30 movies out of the 46 are good in this lot, it still is a heck of a deal on all of the movies.

Month List

Tag cloud